Written by Chuck Martin and Mitchell Hurwitz.
Oscar: Look who’s back. Let’s all say hello.
Buster: And while you’re at it, let’s all give me a big hand.
Lucille: George Michael, get your uncle a bandage for his forehead.
Oscar: And while you’re at it, get two.
George Michael: Oh, my God.
Buster: I guess this means you don’t want to play “Got your nose” with me.
George Michael: (Laughs.)
G.O.B.: What’s the matter, Buster? Did you hurt yourself?
Buster: Hi, G.O.B..
G.O.B.: Oh, my God! What happened to your...? He’s got no hand!
Michael: Buster went swimming in the ocean and according to him, a seal with a bow tie bit off his hand.
G.O.B.: Bow tie?
Tobias: It’s merely the playful mutterings of the shock victim. A seal would never prey on a human, unless, of course, it had acquired a taste for mammal blood.
Buster: This one had a yellow bow tie!
G.O.B.: Really?
Narrator: And later, Lucille could not contain her guilt any longer.
Lucille: I did this. I prayed that God take anything he wanted from us so that Buster wouldn’t have to go to war.
Michael: Mom, after all these years, God’s not going to take a call from you.
G.O.B.: Still, I could hunt down that seal.
Michael: Well, they said if you retrieve Buster’s hand, they might be able to do a transplant.
G.O.B.: At the very least, I could remove that incriminating bow tie.
Narrator: And Michael told Lindsay about his commitment to Maggie and the child that wasn’t his.
Lindsay: Well, first of all, I’m sure there are writers on The Simpsons who aren’t geeks, and secondly, I think this commitment you’re making is great.
Michael: It is. It’s great. It’s great. I do think something might be up, though? What if she’s still lying?
Lindsay: Oh, no. You’re trying to get out of this, aren’t you? I thought you were a good guy.
Michael: I am a good guy.
Tobias: Is he trying to get out of having this baby?
Lindsay: We want this child. It’s given us a reason to stay together.
Narrator: In fact, it was investigating the pregnancy that had re-ignited Lindsay and Tobias’ passion.
Narrator: It was weird.
Michael: Where’s your child?
Lindsay: I don’t have a child, Michael.
Tobias: Oh.
Lindsay: Oh. Did you mean Maeby?
Michael: I did mean Maeby.
